Read e-book online A Defense of Hume on Miracles (Princeton Monographs in PDF

By Robert J. Fogelin

ISBN-10: 1400825776

ISBN-13: 9781400825776

On account that its ebook within the mid-eighteenth century, Hume's dialogue of miracles has been the objective of serious and sometimes ill-tempered assaults. during this e-book, certainly one of our best historians of philosophy bargains a scientific reaction to those attacks.

Arguing that those criticisms have--from the very start--rested on misreadings, Robert Fogelin starts off by way of supplying a story of ways Hume's argument truly unfolds. What Hume's critics (and even a few of his defenders) have didn't see is that Hume's basic argument relies on solving the suitable criteria of comparing testimony awarded on behalf of a miracle. Given the definition of a miracle, Hume really kind of argues that the criteria for comparing such testimony needs to be super excessive. Hume then argues that, actually, no testimony on behalf of a non secular miracle has even come just about assembly the best criteria for recognition. Fogelin illustrates that Hume's critics have always misunderstood the constitution of this argument--and have saddled Hume with completely lousy arguments no longer present in the textual content. He responds first to a few early critics of Hume's argument after which to 2 contemporary critics, David Johnson and John Earman. Fogelin's aim, even if, isn't to "bash the bashers," yet quite to teach that Hume's remedy of miracles has a coherence, intensity, and gear that makes it nonetheless the simplest paintings at the topic.

Show description

Read or Download A Defense of Hume on Miracles (Princeton Monographs in Philosophy) PDF

Similar theology books

New PDF release: The Edge of Words: God and the Habits of Language

The sting of phrases is Rowan Williams’ first booklet on account that status down as Archbishop of Canterbury. Invited to offer the celebrated 2014 Gifford Lectures, Dr Williams has produced a scholarly yet eminently obtainable account of the probabilities of talking approximately God – taking as his aspect of departure the venture of average theology.

Paul C. Jong's Have You Truly Been Born Again of Water and the Spirit? PDF

This is often the 1st ebook during this age to evangelise the gospel of the baptism and the blood of Jesus because it is written within the Scriptures. the real gospel basically tells us that He took away all our sins via His baptism and took over judgment for all our sins at the go. i'm certain that there's no different e-book that preaches ‘the gospel of the water and the blood’ extra in actual fact and faithfully than this one.

Download e-book for iPad: The Modern Theologians: An Introduction to Christian by David F. Ford, Rachel Muers

Like its better half quantity from Blackwell (`The Medieval Theologians'), this article, `The glossy Theologians', edited by way of David Ford, presents an excellent in-depth and broad-ranging advent to 20th century theology. in reality, the trendy interval which Ford delineates is post-World warfare I to the current; in lots of methods, the 1st global conflict supplied a defining turning aspect for far of highbrow historical past, and theology used to be no exception.

Download e-book for kindle: Forever You. A Book About Your Soul and Body by Nicole Lataif

Wake up young ones a long time 4-8 to the enjoyment and secret of being human and support them construct the principles in their Christian religion! The soul's lifelong presence, non secular nature, dating to the physique, substance and starting place, hyperlink to humanity, sacredness, service-directed objective, and eternality are explored within the context of John Paul II's Theology of the physique.

Additional resources for A Defense of Hume on Miracles (Princeton Monographs in Philosophy)

Sample text

For I own, that otherwise, there may possibly be miracles, or violations of the usual course of nature, of such a kind as to admit of proof from human testimony; though, perhaps, it will be impossible to find any such in all the records of history. Thus, suppose, all authors, in all languages, agree, that, from the first of JANUARY 1600, there was a total darkness over the whole earth for eight days: Suppose that the tradition of this extraordinary event is still strong and lively among the people: That all travellers, who return from foreign countries, bring us accounts of the same tradition, without the least variation or contradiction: It is evident, that our present philosophers, instead of doubting the fact, ought to receive it as certain, and ought to search for the causes whence it might be derived.

Of the probability of chances 12. Of the probability of causes 13. Of unphilosophical probability These sections raise serious problems of interpretation, for Hume sometimes seems to slide back and forth between two activities: offering something like an analysis of probability judgments, and giving a causal account of how such judgments are formed. Hume seems to slide back and forth between a descriptive and a normative standpoint.

Nor is it plausible that [this] is what Hume thought, even if it is not what he explicitly says. For one thing, this reading would make it hard to understand the function of the famous Maxim which Hume enunciates at the close of Part 1. . For another thing, Part 2 would be puzzling since there Hume allows that especially good testimony can establish the credibility of some secular miracles. Thus, I will assume . . that in Part 1 Hume did not mean to foreclose the issue of whether testimony could establish the credibility of a miracle, although I acknowledge that the text is ambiguous enough to allow [this] reading.

Download PDF sample

A Defense of Hume on Miracles (Princeton Monographs in Philosophy) by Robert J. Fogelin


by George
4.4

Rated 4.20 of 5 – based on 18 votes